Top 5 Netflix Series Like Wednesday for Your Supernatural Mystery Fix
If you’re one of the millions captivated by the gothic charm, snarky humor, and supernatural mystery of Netflix’s Wednesday, you’re probably craving more. The unique blend of a murder mystery, a school for outcasts, and Tim Burton’s signature style created a phenomenon. The good news is that Netflix has a treasure trove of shows that capture that same spirit.
This guide will walk you through the top 5 Netflix series like Wednesday, each offering its own take on dark academia, teenage sleuthing, and the supernatural. We’ve curated this list based on key elements like tone, themes, and setting to ensure your next binge-watch is just as thrilling.
The Top 5 Netflix Series Like Wednesday
Here are the five best series to add to your queue.
1. Chilling Adventures of Sabrina
The Best Choice for a Direct Supernatural Successor
- Genre: Supernatural Horror, Teen Drama
- IMDB Rating: 7.4/10
If you loved Nevermore Academy, you’ll feel right at home at the Academy of Unseen Arts. Chilling Adventures of Sabrina reimagines the classic comic book character with a dark, horror-infused twist. The series follows Sabrina Spellman, a half-witch, half-mortal teenager, on her 16th birthday as she must choose between the mortal world and her witch heritage.
Why It’s a Perfect Match:
- Strong Female Lead: Sabrina, like Wednesday, is fiercely independent, challenges authority, and is unafraid to dabble in dark magic to protect her friends and family.
- Supernatural School Setting: The Academy is a direct parallel to Nevermore, filled with its own cliques, dark secrets, and ancient traditions.
- Tone: The show masterfully blends horror, dark fantasy, and teen drama with a macabre sense of humor. It’s arguably the closest you can get to the Wednesday vibe on Netflix.
2. Lockwood & Co.
The Best Choice for Supernatural Mystery and Team Chemistry
- Genre: Supernatural Mystery, Action
- IMDB Rating: 7.4/10
This critically acclaimed series is a hidden gem for fans of ghost-hunting and mystery. In an alternate England where ghosts are a deadly epidemic, only young people can sense the supernatural threat. Lockwood & Co. follows a trio of teen operatives who start their own ghost-hunting agency, operating outside the rigid adult-run system.
Why It’s a Perfect Match:
- Investigative Trio: The dynamic between the cynical Lucy, charismatic Lockwood, and geeky George mirrors the investigative partnership between Wednesday, Enid, and Eugene.
- Supernatural Sleuthing: The entire show is built around solving supernatural cases, each episode unraveling a larger conspiracy, much like the mystery of the Hyde in Wednesday.
- Outsider Spirit: They are underdogs fighting against a skeptical and established system, embodying the outsider spirit central to Wednesday.
Related Stories
Top 5 Netflix Romantic Series With Sizzling Chemistry. The Hottest One Isn’t What You Think (#3 is Pure Fire)
Top 5 Scariest Netflix Movies You MUST Watch | #3 Will Freak You Out!
3. A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder
The Best Choice for a Grounded (But Still Dark) Murder Mystery
- Genre: Mystery, Thriller
- IMDB Rating: 6.8/10
For those who particularly loved the true-crime investigative aspect of Wednesday, this limited series is a must-watch. Starring Emma Myers (who played the vibrant Enid Sinclair), A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder follows Pip Fitz-Amobi, a brilliant high school student who re-opens a closed murder case for her senior project. She becomes obsessed with proving the convicted killer is innocent, uncovering dangerous small-town secrets along the way.
Why It’s a Perfect Match:
- Protagonist Parallels: Pip is Wednesday Addams if she were obsessed with a cold case instead of the supernatural. She is incredibly intelligent, determined, and undeterred by threats.
- Mur Mystery Core: The central whodunit plot is tightly wound and will keep you guessing until the very end, just like the mystery in Wednesday.
- Familiar Face: Seeing Emma Myers in a completely different, yet equally compelling, role is a fantastic bonus.
4. The Umbrella Academy
The Best Choice for Quirky, Dysfunctional Family Dynamics
- Genre: Superhero, Sci-Fi, Drama
- IMDB Rating: 7.8/10
While more sci-fi than gothic, The Umbrella Academy shares DNA with Wednesday through its core themes. The series follows a dysfunctional family of superheroes who reunite after their adoptive father’s death to solve the mystery of his passing and prevent an impending apocalypse.
Why It’s a Perfect Match:
- Family of Misfits: The Hargreeves siblings are the ultimate group of outcasts, each with their own bizarre personalities and traumas, similar to the students of Nevermore.
- Blend of Tone: The show expertly juggles absurdist humor, dark emotional moments, and stylistic action sequences.
- Central Mystery: Each season is driven by a complex mystery that the siblings must work together (often reluctantly) to solve.
5. The Midnight Club
The Best Choice for Gothic Atmosphere and Teen Bonding
- Genre: Horror, Mystery
- IMDB Rating: 6.5/10
From horror master Mike Flanagan, The Midnight Club is set in a mysterious hospice for terminally ill teenagers. The residents meet at midnight to tell scary stories. They make a pact that the first to die will send the others a sign from the afterlife. However, they soon begin to experience supernatural occurrences that suggest the stories might be real.
Why It’s a Perfect Match:
- Gothic Setting: Brightcliffe Manor is a classic gothic setting—creepy, old, and filled with secrets, much like the Ophelia Hall mansion in Wednesday.
- Teen Outsiders: The core group is bound together by their unique and tragic circumstances, forming a tight-knit community of outsiders.
- Spooky Stories: The anthology-style storytelling within the larger mystery provides the same kind of eerie, episodic hooks that Wednesday delivered.
Honorable Mentions
- Stranger Things: The quintessential Netflix mystery show about kids vs. supernatural forces. Less gothic, but same core themes of friendship and investigation.
- The Sandman: A dark, philosophical fantasy epic with a gothic tone and stunning visuals that will appeal to fans of Tim Burton’s style.
- Shadow and Bone: For those who loved the world-building and “chosen one” aspect of Wednesday, this Grishaverse fantasy offers a rich alternative.
What Will You Watch Next?
Whether you’re drawn to the dark academia of Sabrina, the ghost-hunting action of Lockwood & Co., or the true-crime mystery of A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder, there’s a perfect show waiting for you. Each of these series captures the essence of what made Wednesday so special: the celebration of the weird, the power of intelligence, and the thrill of uncovering a dark secret. All these shows available worldwide on netflix.
Happy binging! Share your next choice with us in the comments below.
FAQs:
- What is the most similar Netflix series like wednesday?
- Chilling Adventures of Sabrina is the closest match, featuring a dark supernatural school and a strong, witchy female lead.
- Is there a show like Wednesday without the supernatural elements?
- Yes, A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder captures Wednesday’s murder-mystery and investigative spirit in a real-world setting.
- Which show like Wednesday is best for ghost stories?
- Lockwood & Co. is a perfect pick for thrilling ghost-hunting action and a team of young investigators solving supernatural mysteries.
